November 12, 2008
Systems Thinking, Part 1– Definition
When I look back on the issues I see many of my clients facing today, “lack of systems thinking” tops the list of “how did we get this way?” answers. Systems thinking, to define the term a bit, is the ability to understand not only the process you are examining, but also how that process fits into the overall picture, and what the interrelationships of these processes are.
Since ’systems thinking’ is not a common term, I keep two of my favorite examples of system thinking, that most folks seem to ‘get’, in my back pocket. These are:
- The conductor of the symphony orchestra: Not only does s/he have to ensure that each piece is working the way it’s supposed to, s/he has to ensure that everything is in balance. Sub-optimization occurs when the conductor starts to focus on one area - say, strings - more than the others, bringing the string section volume up to the point where it starts to negatively affect the overall piece being played. A good conductor will ensure that all sections of the symphony are in balance, producing an optimized product - the piece being performed.
- General contractor on a house/office building build: The contractor has the responsibility to understand what each group is contracted to do, and to ensure that the steps are done in the correct order. We don’t want the sheetrock installers putting up walls before we have the plumbing and electrical conduits run; it’ll make the job lots harder. And, let’s not install the wood floors until we have the roof on, OK, guys? Despite what you may see on Extreme Makeover, Home Edition, most jobs are not done by hundreds of folks at once. The general contractor is responsible for bringing in the build on time, to budget, and with no “oops”. S/he does this by keeping in mind what the final product will be - and then ensuring that each piece is completed in alignment with the overall design/purpose.
So now that we have systems thinking defined, why do so many folks find it hard to do so? I think it may be because we are focused on the details as part of our makeup. We’ve been taught, and often rewarded, for attention to detail. If we want to have a big breakfast on the weekend, we have to:
- decide on the menu (bacon and pancakes with orange juice and fresh fruit)
- go shopping for ingredients missing
- prepare each item per directions (bacon crispy, pancakes cooked but not burned, etc.)
- figure out how to get them all on the table, at the correct temperature (orange juice and fruit cold, bacon and pancakes hot), within 2 mins of each other
- etc.
Now we take that talent for detail thinking, and say, “Great! Let’s think about this at the systems level.” Systems level? What the heck is that? I’m just trying to get the kids’ pancakes cooked so they look like Mickey Mouse and they’re not soggy!
Systems thinking might involve how breakfast fits into the other activities for the day - “I want to give the kids a big breakfast so we don’t have to stop for lunch when we’re out running errands”; or “since they like pancakes, I’ll tell them they have to be dressed and ready to go out before allowing them to sit down at breakfast - that’ll get them motivated to stop watching cartoons and to get dressed”. It might also involve their health - either “getting some meat on them bones” by starting them out with a hearty breakfast, or making a conscious decision to feed them something less that fully nutritional (bacon) as a treat.
I hope you have the idea of what I mean by systems thinking. These non-business examples should be something that anyone in any business can relate to. Now that we’ve defined systems thinking, stay tuned for our next installment when we discuss/demonstrate some business examples of when systems thinking saves the day… and to be sure you don’t miss it, feel free to click on the RSS or fave links!
|
|
|
|
|
![]() |




Len Green said,
November 28, 2008 @ 9:16 pm
Mary
I like the thread here, I see it often with clients. I was curious about whether your term “systems thinking” is perhaps hinting at “systematic thinking” because while computer systems may be a part of the solution, the approach needs to be “systematic” and factor in people and process as well as technology?
Your thoughts?
Best regards,
Len
admin said,
November 30, 2008 @ 12:40 am
Hi Len,
Thanks for your thoughtful comment. Actually, I was thinking of Management Systems when I wrote this - hence the ’systems’ reference. While systematic is a key factor in this, do you think that ’systems thinking’ is appropriate given my frame of reference? I am unaware of whether the term systems is an exclusive reference to computer systems or not…
Regards,
Mary
Nora Femenia said,
December 2, 2008 @ 3:19 pm
Hi,
I want to point that the lack of acceptance/understanding and generalized use of a systems thinking approach has surprised me a lot. I grew up reading George Miller “Living Systems,” a wonderful book that forced my brain to think in a systemic way (what are the unwanted consequences of today’s decision that will hit me tomorrow?. Then I did systemic family therapy for a long time and understood how systemic variables shaped human interactions. This is a very humanistic frame that helps change fast!
When I did manage to escape my country and live here in the US, was sadly surprised by the almost denial of systems thinking in science. Later I understood that this misuse had a reason: we don’t want to think in owning the consequences of our actions! We can accept environment pollution because that is part of development and money generation, but we need not to care about who is going to pay for the consequences….
I live in Florida, and for me is easy to link environmental degradation and its impact on wild animals with uncontrolled land development. Usually, the media and the public doesn’t make the connection. It involves becoming responsible for the long term consequences of our actions…. The present crisis, read in systemic terms is not more than “chicken coming home to roost”…we are not only victims, but we created the conditions for this crisis, and looking at the situation in this way helps produce the necessary solutions: own the responsibility and behave in a dfferent way!
Systems Thinking, Part 2 - Application | Improve My Business said,
December 11, 2008 @ 2:24 pm
[...] Part 1 of Systems Thinking post, I talked about how systems thinking can be used to see how our actions and task fit into the [...]